Burgatory Restaurant in Pittsburgh, PA

Sharing is caring!

You might have seen my post about Enrico Biscotti — another unique eating place, but today I want to tell you about the Burgatory Restaurant — the ultimate place to get a delicious burger, fries, and milkshake right in the heart of Pittsburgh, PA.

During my recent trip, I volunteered at the West PA animal shelter. I had the opportunity to eat at another unique restaurant.

What sets Burgatory apart isn’t just the quality of its ingredients — locally sourced, fresh, and flavorful — but the way it puts creative control in the hands of the diner. Whether you're a traditionalist who loves a classic cheeseburger or an adventurous eater trying bison or Wagyu with exotic toppings, Burgatory has something to satisfy your craving.

From the moment that we stepped foot into Burgatory, this beef-loving woman was home. Y'all, the place smells heavenly!

And of course, you have to take photos of the environment when you are there — because it is so unique.

Burgatory Restaurant is The Most Unique Burger Joint

Burgatory’s vibe matches its food: fun, relaxed, and perfect for groups. Whether you’re grabbing a bite before a game, dining with family, or catching up with friends, the energy is lively without being overwhelming. Many locations, like the one near PNC Park and Acrisure Stadium, are popular with sports fans and visitors alike.

What makes The Burgatory Restaurant so unique is the way that you can order your burger. Now, they have traditional menus made up of all their burgers available.

They offer gluten-free options, vegetarian options, changing out beef for chicken, and more.

But my favorite way to order a burger is the Custom Creations menu that they offer. I have a specific taste when it comes to a chicken burger; being able to choose everything I wanted on the burger was pure perfection.

The burger I created was an all-natural chicken burger as the base. Seasoned with jerk seasoning and then topped with grilled pineapple, arugula, and bacon. I do believe that it was the best burger I have ever put in my mouth.

One of Burgatory’s biggest draws (and insider tips) is taking advantage of the custom burger experience:

• Pick your protein — beef, bison, Wagyu, elk, or plant-based Impossible.
• Choose from tons of rubs, cheeses, sauces, and toppings (including adventurous options like pork belly, au poivre sauce, and even peanut butter).
  Locals recommend the pretzel bun and smoked gouda combo for something rich and flavorful.

Another thing that makes Burgatory Restaurant unique is the way they serve the fries. They have quite a few on their appetizer menu, so the group I was with ordered about 5 or 6 different versions and passed them around the table.

My favorite were the ones that were topped with Gorgonzola cheese, green onions, and a garlic and herb spice.

Out of this world desserts at Burgatory Restaurant

Their homemade one-of-a-kind milkshakes are the perfect way to end your fabulous meal. I ordered a Caramel Pretzel milkshake that was out of this world delicious.

The flavors are unique and insane. In fact, Burgatory has been named as having the top milkshake in the world.

Burgatory has several locations, all located in Pennsylvania. They are locally owned and operated.

In addition to the flagship, Burgatory has expanded throughout the Pittsburgh area, including:

• Burgatory – North Shore – A great stop between stadium events and North Shore outings.
• Burgatory – Homestead – A laid-back location near The Waterfront with all the signature burger and shake options.

Each location keeps the core concept intact while adding its own local charm.

The next time you are in Pittsburgh, be sure to find one and go have yourself a unique burger experience.

Looking for another fun and unique experience? Check out these free Pittsburgh walking tours. This city is one of a kind and should be explored thoroughly!